**Practical Magic 2** opened in theaters on September 10, 2026, with early critic reviews driving its Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer firmly into the low 30s percent range, consistent with the original 1998 film’s 30% score. The 108-plus reviews highlight mixed-to-negative consensus on the script and direction from Susanne Bier, though Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman’s chemistry and the returning supporting cast earn consistent praise. Audience scores have climbed to the low 90s percent from verified ratings, echoing the first film’s cult appeal. With the review count already substantial and no major new batches expected to shift the percentage dramatically, trader focus centers on whether the score settles below or above key thresholds like 40% before the market resolves, alongside strong opening-weekend box office tracking that suggests fan support may not move critic aggregates.